With NRW’s consultation on the next cycle of the Water Framework Directive due next week, we ask stakeholders in Wales to start thinking about what isn’t working and what we need instead.

Natural Resources Wales (NRW) says its latest classification, for 2024 and published in March 2025, “has remained steady”, with 40% of Wales’ water bodies in good or better condition. The figures for rivers tell a less reassuring story.

More rivers failing now than in 2021

Under the Water Framework Directive (WFD), NRW classifies Wales’ 717 river stretches, known as waterbodies, from high to bad, with a target of at least good by 2027. In 2024, 411 (57%) fell short of good, up from 402 in 2021, and those classified poor or bad, the two lowest grades, rose from 69 to 92.

More have declined than improved since 2021: 99 dropped at least one grade and 72 improved. The pattern holds even setting aside changes caused by differences in what was monitored.

Afonydd Cymru analysis of NRW WFD river classifications: Cycle 3 baseline (2021) and interim (2024), 717 river waterbodies.

Since 2018 the picture is more mixed: slightly fewer are failing (411 against 432), and about as many improved as declined. But, most disappointingly, more rivers are in the worst condition, with poor or bad rising at every classification, from 58 to 69 to 92.

Fish are failing, and it's getting worse…

More rivers fail for fish than for anything else, rising from 174 in 2021 to 205 in 2024. Where fish were assessed at all three classifications, the proportion failing rose each time, from 29% to 34% to 39%, and 107 of the 140 failing in 2018 are still failing.

Fish are also where the reasons for failure are least clear.

When a river fails, the law requires the causes to be investigated, and NRW records what it finds, including who is responsible, such as farming or the water industry. In its October 2025 list of reasons for failure, 112 river waterbodies have a fish-related reason. The most common is barriers, such as weirs and culverts, that stop fish moving along the river (63). But in 41, more than a third, NRW has not identified who is responsible for at least one reason. For phosphate, it has in every case.

Failing, with no reason recorded

NRW should publish why each river is failing. Without that reason, it is hard to target action.

In the October 2025 list, more than a third of failing river waterbodies (151 of 411, 37%) have no reason recorded. Of those, 91 were already failing in 2021, and 55 of the 91 have never had a reason recorded in either the 2022 or 2025 list. With no reason on record, no one has been made responsible for fixing them.

Look, and you will find

Where NRW has started assessing something new, it has often found problems. In 2024, NRW assessed cypermethrin in 60 river waterbodies where it had not been assessed in 2018 or 2021, and 20 failed. Cypermethrin, an insecticide withdrawn from sheep dip because of the harm it did to rivers, is still used in pour-on sheep treatments. PAHs, pollutants from burning fuel that reach rivers from roads and industry, show the same pattern: 13 of 14 river waterbodies newly assessed since 2021 failed.

Accurate classification depends on monitoring, and as our recent piece on NRW’s water quality archive showed, routine monitoring has fallen sharply. A problem that isn’t measured can’t show up as a failure.

Afonydd Cymru analysis of NRW WFD river classifications: Cycle 3 baseline (2021) and interim (2024), 717 river waterbodies

Who is accountable?

Failures put down to water companies go into five-yearly investment plans, although plans agreed years in advance can mean newer problems wait for the next one. There is no equivalent process for most other sectors, including farming, the sector named most often (142 failing river waterbodies), so those failures can carry on from one cycle to the next.

What Afonydd Cymru are asking for

With the 2027 deadline a year away, we question what has been delivered in the 26 years since the Directive was adopted, and whether funding could have been used more effectively. We call for:

  • An independent review of the WFD in Wales, looking at how Welsh funding and resources could be used to achieve more.
  • A specific plan, with clear deadlines, for every failing river waterbody, rather than general national measures.
  • A deadline for investigating failures, so no river is left failing without a recorded reason.
  • Appropriate monitoring to know the true state of our rivers, including surveys designed for fish other than salmon and trout, such as bullhead.
  • Every sector held responsible for its share, not only the water industry.

Read our full updated report and support rivers in Wales by responding to the NRW consultation when it’s launched next week.

Unless stated otherwise, figures are our analysis of NRW’s WFD river classifications  (2018 Cycle 2, 2021 Cycle 3 baseline and 2024 Cycle 3 interim) and NRW’s Reasons for Not Achieving Good lists (October 2022 and October 2025). Changes in classification can reflect changes in monitoring and methods as well as in the river itself.